This week, the Supreme Court addressed debates on executive power, Justice Sotomayor’s advocacy for judicial restraint, and the indictment of a prominent legal figure. Also this week, the Supreme Court saw Justice Sotomayor’s new book announcement, a case on DNA testing, and a public approval rating above 50%.
Over the past week, the U.S. Supreme Court and its justices have been involved in several noteworthy activities:
- Justice Sonia Sotomayor Announces New Children’s Book: Justice Sotomayor revealed her upcoming children’s picture book, “Just Shine! How to Be a Better You,” inspired by her late mother. The book, illustrated by Jacqueline Alcántara, is set to release on September 9 and aims to encourage children to recognize and nurture the unique qualities in others. people.com
- Justice Sotomayor Emphasizes Adherence to the Rule of Law: In a recent statement, Justice Sotomayor highlighted that U.S. presidents have historically complied with judicial rulings, with few exceptions. She underscored the importance of the judiciary’s cautious approach to maintain the balance of power, referencing the landmark case Marbury v. Madison, which established the judiciary’s role in interpreting the constitutionality of laws. apnews.com
- Supreme Court to Hear Case on DNA Testing for Death Row Inmate: The Court has agreed to consider the plea of a death row inmate seeking DNA testing to prove his innocence. The case centers on the inmate’s request for access to DNA evidence that was previously denied, raising significant questions about post-conviction rights and the use of forensic technology in the justice system. scotusblog.com
- Public Approval of the Supreme Court Above 50%: A recent Marquette Law School Poll indicates that public approval of the U.S. Supreme Court stands above 50%. This reflects a majority of respondents expressing confidence in the Court’s decisions and its role within the American legal framework. wtmj.com
- Legal Community Reacts to Indictment of SCOTUSblog Founder:
- Tom Goldstein, a prominent attorney known for founding SCOTUSblog and arguing numerous cases before the Supreme Court, has been indicted on 22 counts, including tax evasion and using his law firm to settle gambling debts. This development has sent shockwaves through the legal community, given Goldstein’s influential role in Supreme Court litigation and legal commentary. The case raises questions about ethics and accountability within the legal profession. nymag.com
- Discussions on Presidential Term Limits Amid Trump’s Third-Term Hints:
- Former President Donald Trump’s suggestions about seeking a third term have ignited debates regarding the 22nd Amendment, which restricts presidents to two terms. Legal experts contend that altering this constitutional provision would require a rigorous amendment process, involving substantial congressional and state support. While some propose potential loopholes, such as Trump serving as Vice President first, these scenarios face significant constitutional challenges. The Supreme Court’s role could be pivotal if such unprecedented legal questions arise. time.com
- Justice Sotomayor Honored with Brandeis Medal:
- The University of Louisville’s Brandeis School of Law awarded Justice Sonia Sotomayor its highest honor, the Brandeis Medal, recognizing her commitment to public service and social justice. In her acceptance, Justice Sotomayor reflected on the importance of empathy and understanding in the judiciary, echoing the values of Justice Louis D. Brandeis, after whom the medal is named. news.louisville.edu
Bibliography:
- “Justice Sonia Sotomayor to Release New Children’s Book ‘Just Shine!’ About Being Yourself (Exclusive).” People, February 13, 2025. people.com
- “Sotomayor says presidents have largely followed rule of law, offers words of caution.” Associated Press, February 12, 2025. apnews.com
- “Supreme Court to consider death row plea for DNA testing.” SCOTUSblog, February 13, 2025. scotusblog.com
- “U.S. Supreme Court approval above 50% in Marquette Law School Poll.” WTMJ, February 13, 2025. wtmj.com
- “‘Unitary executive’ theory may reach Supreme Court as Trump wields sweeping power.” Reuters, February 14, 2025. reuters.com
- “Sotomayor says presidents have largely followed rule of law, offers words of caution.” Associated Press, February 12, 2025. apnews.com
- “The Legal Star Who Ran Out of Luck.” New York Magazine, February 14, 2025. nymag.com
- “Donald Trump Keeps Teasing a Third Term. Here’s What to Know.” Time, February 14, 2025. time.com
- “U.S. Supreme Court Justice Sonia Sotomayor awarded highest honor from UofL Brandeis School of Law.” University of Louisville News, February 14, 2025. news.louisville.edu
